Home / Ask Steve / Buying in the Florida Keys
Buying a Home

How do I choose the right Keys community?

Steve Conley | August 24, 2026

Short Answer

Consider your lifestyle priorities: proximity to Miami (Key Largo), sport fishing (Islamorada), family activities (Marathon), privacy and space (Big Pine Key), or arts and nightlife (Key West). Each island offers a distinct Keys experience.

Consider your lifestyle priorities: proximity to Miami (Key Largo), sport fishing (Islamorada), family activities (Marathon), privacy and space (Big Pine Key), or arts and nightlife (Key West). Each island offers a distinct Keys experience.

If you have a specific situation or property in mind, I encourage you to reach out directly. Every real estate transaction in the Florida Keys has unique factors, and a conversation is the best way to get the precise guidance you need. My team and I are here to help you navigate the process with confidence.

Text me at (305) 393-5859 or send a message through the contact page and I will get back to you personally.

Steve Conley

Steve's Advice

Steve Conley

Principal, Conley Sales Group at COMPASS

I always tell buyers to spend at least one full day in each community they are considering before making an offer. Drive the streets at different times of day. Eat at the local restaurants. Check the grocery store. The right community is the one that feels like home to you, not the one that looks best in a listing photo.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Whether you are buying, selling, or just exploring the Florida Keys, Steve is here to help.